Knights of Columbus planning to replace traditional uniform

| Tony Gutierrez | August 9, 2017 | 5 Comments

Members of the Knights of Columbus are seen in their new uniforms Aug. 1 during the international fraternal organization’s 135th annual Supreme Convention in St. Louis. The new uniform is replacing the traditional regalia worn by fourth-degree Knights, announced Supreme Knight Carl Anderson Aug. 1 during the convention. CNS photo/Knights of Columbus

The Knights of Columbus, long associated with swords, capes and chapeaus, will be going through a significant uniform change.

The traditional regalia worn by fourth-degree Knights will be replaced, announced Supreme Knight Carl Anderson Aug. 1 during the international fraternal organization’s 135th annual Supreme Convention in St. Louis, which was livestreamed on EWTN.

Throughout the years, the regalia of the Knights’ fourth degree, known as the patriotic degree, has gone through changes, Anderson said, noting that when this degree was first established, the uniform included white ties, top hats and tails.

In place of a tuxedo with a black bow tie, members will be wearing a blue blazer, an official Knights of Columbus tie and a beret, all with the fourth-degree emblem on them, along with a white shirt and dark gray slacks. There was no mention if the swords would remain part of the uniform.

“The board of directors has decided that the time is right for a modernization of the fourth-degree uniform,” Anderson said. “On a limited basis, assemblies may choose to continue using the traditional cape and chapeau for color corps at public events and honor guards in liturgical processions. However, the preferred dress for the fourth degree, including color corps and honor guards, is the new uniform of jacket and beret.”

Robert Earl, a member of the Father Novatus Assembly 23, which serves Our Lady of Perpetual Help and St. Daniel the Prophet parishes in Scottsdale, welcomes the new changes.

“I feel it is significant that the order changes to respond to changing times. The new uniform evokes an image of elite military corpsmen in my mind, and I believe this is the intent behind the change,” Earl told The Catholic Sun, newspaper of the Diocese of Phoenix.

“Our former regalia was reminiscent of Navy officers and consistent with the nautical theme in the patriotic degree, but it perhaps did not have currency in the minds of the general public,” he added, noting that in addition to the tuxedo, the other items collectively could cost approximately $500. “I think the new uniform creates a positive and striking image of ‘soldiers for Christ,’ which is, after all, what we are meant to be.”

Many members are not as thrilled about the pending changes, which generated some controversy among the membership. Joseph Meyer from Msgr. Bernard G. Collins Assembly 2899, which serves St. Bridget and Christ the King parishes in Mesa, said the new uniforms lose a sense of the pageantry associated with the Knights’ fourth-degree level.

Knights of Columbus process in their current uniform of tuxedos, capes and chapeaus in this 2014 file photo. Dave Hrbacek/The Catholic Spirit

“I have been a fourth-degree Knight since 1978 and we have always had this regalia,” said Meyer, who was a color corps commander in Toledo, Ohio. for 13 years before moving to Arizona. “We all looked great in the fourth-degree outfits. These (new) outfits look bad.”

Meyer also expressed concern for members who own the current uniform and have to spend money on the new one.

“If we get a new uniform like this, you will see a lot of Knights leave the degree. A lot of your Knights are retired and don’t have over $500 to spend,” he said.

Paul Lee, a member of the Iowa delegation who spoke to The Catholic Sun from St. Louis, said the reaction on the ground was “mixed.”

“The largest concern is people don’t feel that they have answers for the question of why the need for the change. They want something beyond a more modern look,” said Lee.

Lee said many members he’s interacted with are excited about the changes because it brings the uniform “more in line with other military service organizations because it connects us as patriotic organizations.” There also are members who “don’t like change, so they’re already up in arms,” he added.

“Then you have the sect of folks that feel that their voice was not consulted, (that) this sort of change should have taken place as discussion at the state council level and then brought concerns to the Supreme level,” said Lee, who countered that notion by saying conversations have been happening at all levels of the order about the need for change.

Representatives of the Arizona State Council said it was too early to comment as program details and guidelines for implementing the new uniforms were still unavailable.

Gutierrez is editor of The Catholic Sun, newspaper of the Diocese of Phoenix.

Tags: , , , , ,

Category: Featured, U.S. & World News

  • Charles C.

    At one of the two major suppliers of fourth degree gear, the price for a complete set of regalia (sword, chapeau, cape, tux, carrying case, gloves, sword case, garment bag, everything) is $410. The new uniform, as listed on the Knights of Columbus website, costs $510. For the $510 you get a blazer, trousers, necktie, and beret. That’s it. The pricing doesn’t make any sense.

    And the price isn’t the only thing that doesn’t make any sense. The old uniforms added color with cape linings of red, white, purple, green, gold, or sky blue. Even the plumes on the chapeaus might be of different colors. Now everyone will wear a navy blue jacket. Can anyone think of anything more boring, more corporate, than a navy blue blazer?

    In the past, the Knights brought a sense of history, symbolism, pageantry, and drama. Observers knew something special was happening when the Knights came into view. They were associated with churches, processions, and various special masses. Now the Knights will present the picture of a bunch of World War II veterans who have spent the last fifty years as accountants.

    Yes, the berets look more like current military headgear, but so what? The fourth is a patriotic degree, not a military degree.

    “I feel it is significant that the order changes to respond to changing times. The new uniform evokes an image of elite military corpsmen in my mind, and I believe this is the intent behind the change,”

    If the above statement is correct, then the Knights have gone the wrong way. For the Church or its attendant organizations, to respond to changing times is always a risky move. Sometimes it is necessary, but not as often as people seem to think. Further, the degree is not about “elite military corpsmen.” Does the speaker want us to mow down Muslims, Methodists, and Unitarians? The fourth degree, I repeat, is not a military degree. There’s no sense in wearing a uniform trying to pretend it is.

    (As an aside, when someone was wearing the old uniform, everyone knew who he was. There is no way to identify the organization wearing the new uniform unless you’re close enough to read the badges.)

  • Laura J. Podgorny Perry

    As a 4th degree knight I can say I will not be purchasing this uniform. My wife does not like the new uniform. My council does not like it and not one 4th degree I have spoken to is planning on buying it. I will refuse an honor guard wearing this uniform. We are Knights. We are Catholic. We are conservative in beliefs. We’re are in this world yet not of it and will not confirm to it for acceptance. We say NO to the uniform.

    • Charles C.

      May I offer one possibility? Or perhaps create a possibility in your mind based on several facts.

      1.) Supreme doesn’t have “Uniform police.”

      2.) Supreme might not appreciate the publicity involved in disbanding an assembly for uniform violations. (Not to mention the loss in Fourth Degree members which would result.)

      3.) At wakes and funerals many families have specifically requested our assembly attend in full regalia.

      4.) After the deadline there will just happen to be a group of men in town with regalia. Except for a badge or two, there won’t be anything on it that says “Knights of Columbus.” So, if those guys just get together and decide to wear that outfit to some event or church function, what’s the harm? If Gays can attend Mass with rainbow sashes, why can’t a group of men show up with baldrics?

      Just a thought or two.

      • Edward Perry

        Ah but in this situation as you said it would still just be a bunch of guys dressed in regalia. Not officially representing the knights of Columbus. Sure it’s splitting hairs but I pose a question… What do you think father McGivney would have to say about all this?

        • Charles C.

          You are absolutely right on both counts, it is splitting hairs and it wouldn’t be official. This idea was provided by our Navigator when faced with the possibility that most (if not all) of the Honor Guard would refuse to shell out the $500 + to get the new version when they didn’t like the looks of it.

          If the guard “quits” then there is no presence of the Fourth Degree at all. I believe he is trying to find some compromise.

          As far as Father McGivney goes, I’m not sure. The guard is, after all, voluntary and many wonder if the new uniform makes the Knights or the Church more attractive. At our last 3rd degree meeting, a young member said he knew of two young men who were cancelling their 4th degree exemplification over the uniform flap. (For new people coming in the cost is $650 + as they have to get a sword as well. Kind of eliminates the new young members just starting in life.) Perhaps he would suggest calming down for a month or two, then praying about it.

          Great response, thank you.