How should we think about our past?

| Father Michael Schmitz | January 11, 2017 | 0 Comments


Q. How much weight should I give to my past? I’ve been told that I need to forget the past and move forward, but it seems like there ought to be something more to it.

A. When it comes to the past, many of us are tempted to fall into one of two traps: Either we choose to ignore the past or we choose to live in the past. Yet, both of these choices will prevent us from accomplishing one of the principal ends in life — becoming wise.

Becoming wise is one of the goals of a life well lived. More important than pleasure, more lasting than fitness and more attainable than wealth, wisdom is enduring, available to all and proper to the human person.

Historically, however, wisdom has been seen as the result of acquiring two things: truth and experience.

We ignore the past when we don’t stop to evaluate and appreciate what we have experienced. When we fail to recognize the way our decisions have impacted our lives and the lives of those around us, and when we fail to acknowledge the ways other people’s decisions have impacted our lives, we are short-circuiting one of the essential ingredients for becoming wise.

To ignore one’s past can be absolutely devastating to a good life. We can see this in our own experience, or in the experience of the people around us. We all know the person who consistently dates one jerk after another. Rather than learning from their past, this person not only continues to date jerks, but also the same kind of jerk! To these people, I like to refer to the quote: “Everything happens for a reason. Sometimes that reason is you are foolish and make bad decisions.” That might be harsh (although of course it is merely meant as a lighthearted way of pointing out our tendency to make unwise choices), but it is also often true of those who refuse to acknowledge the past.

If wisdom comes as a result of combining truth with experience, then in order to become wise, one must look at one’s past and assess it. This is one of the incredible benefits from the practice of regularly examining one’s conscience.

Even more than an “examination of conscience,” I would recommend something called a “consciousness examen.” That might sound like the same thing, but they are significantly different. With a consciousness examen, we will, at least once a day, stop and review our day. Beginning by asking the Holy Spirit for guidance, we go over our day, looking for times God was present. Essentially, we are looking for the ways God had spoken to us through the day or blessed us during that day. After acknowledging God’s presence and action, we thank God. Then, we review our day again, being attentive to all of the times God was trying to speak to us or invite us to act, but we said no to God’s invitation. After looking at and assessing these times, we repent of them (we ask God to forgive us and resolve to turn to him more in the future).

This process, repeated on a regular basis, will help a person grow in wisdom. Rather than simply “going through the motions” and drifting through life, we will begin to move through life with intentionality and purpose. Our choices (both good and bad) will have the ability to become the necessary fuel for wisdom and will help us chart a course for the future.

We will avoid the incredibly silly trap of saying things like, “Don’t regret anything from your past. It has made you into the person you are today.” That saying is absurd for a number of reasons. The first is that it assumes you have learned from the bad and good choices and are actually a better person today. But all of us know that this is not necessarily the case. Often, our experiences can contribute to our becoming more evil and more foolish. It is only when we look at our past, assess our past, learn from our past and make corrections (aka repent) that we have the potential to become better and wiser.

The other trap many people fall into is to live in the past. I am referring to those people who repeatedly beat themselves up over decisions long gone. There are those who, even after learning from the past and repenting, choose to continue to define themselves by their failures (or by their successes). It is impossible to become wise when one chooses not to learn from the past and then leave it alone. This is because wisdom has to be practical. And practical wisdom is the ability to apply what one has learned to the current situation in order to move forward in the best way possible.

Last thing. There are people who just can’t seem to break free from the past. I have one piece of advice for them: laugh. Laugh at yourself. So many of us are stuck in the past because we take ourselves so seriously. Because of this, every time we remember something bad we have done in the past, we are crippled by it. Christians are the ones who do not need to take themselves so seriously. We take God seriously. We take other people seriously. We need to take sin seriously. But we do not need to take our “drama” so seriously.

If you can take yourself less seriously, you will be free to learn from the past, but not live in the past.

Father Schmitz is director of youth and young adult ministry for the Diocese of Duluth and chaplain of the Newman Center at the University of Minnesota Duluth. Reach him at

Tags: , , ,

Category: Ask Father Mike