Transforming the way parishes communicate...online
Birth mother recalls adoption experience of 50 years ago Print E-mail
By Julie Pfitzinger - For The Catholic Spirit   
Thursday, 05 November 2009
In 1957, when an unmarried 21 year-old Jackie Maher surrendered her newborn daughter to Catholic Charities for adoption, she was emphatically told she would never see her child again. However, something in Maher’s heart told her otherwise.
adoption.jpg
Jackie Maher, right, reconnected with her daughter Katie DeCosse 50 years after giving her up for adoption. Photo by Dave Hrbacek / The Catholic Spirit


Maher said she “just put one foot in front of the other” after the baby was born and went on with her life, eventually marrying and raising five children. Three years ago, Maher, now 74 and a parishioner at St. Vincent de Paul in Brooklyn Park, began actively searching for her daughter.

“I was getting older and wanted to find her, find out if she had any questions only I could answer,” Maher explained, adding that at the time, her other children had no knowledge of  their  sibling. “I didn’t have any idea about the kind of relationship that would come out of our reunion,” she said.

Reunion led to a book

Maher and her 52-year-old daughter Katie DeCosse have co-written a new book called “Fifty Years in 13 Days: A Mother/Daughter Reunion” that details their initial connection via e-mail, and describing how the two reached a place where they were ready to meet and start building a relationship.

After hiring someone to help her find DeCosse, Maher initiated the contact (which she has since learned is more unusual than an adoptee searching for a birth mother) and mailed a letter to her daughter. “I hoped she would respond,” said Maher. “The very next morning, I received an e-mail from her.”

For almost two weeks, the women corresponded back and forth. “We didn’t talk on the phone because Katie said she didn’t want to hear my voice until she could see me,” said Maher.

DeCosse believes the time was right for her to hear from Maher. “The first letter arrived six weeks after I turned 50,” she said. “I really felt like I was mentally prepared for the opportunity.”

In the late 1970s, DeCosse was able to access what was referred to as “non-identifying information” about Maher and her birth father. “There were different things I learned about them, but there were no names,” she said, adding that at that point in her life, she opted not to pursue a further search. “Like many adoptees, I had concerns that I would be rejected again.”

Honoring birth moms


For the past two years, the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, in collaboration with Catholic Charities, has sponsored a Day of Honor and Recognition of Birth Mothers — the only diocese in the country to offer the program, said Gretchen Traylor, one of the event organizers and a member of St. Gerard Majella in Brooklyn Park.

Traylor, herself an adoptee, became interested in creating this special day after she started volunteering as a crisis pregnancy counselor at Birthright. Although she never surrendered a child, Traylor saw the lack of healing opportunities for women like her own birth mother (now deceased).

In July, St. Charles Borromeo parish in St. Anthony hosted the second annual event (the 2010 site has yet to be selected), which included presentations and a Mass.

“For many of these women, it was the first time they spoke about what happened to them or had the chance to meet with others who also surrendered babies for adoption,” said Traylor. “When I think about how powerful and emotional these events have been, I think of when Jesus said, ‘The truth will make you free,’” she said.
Maher is hopeful their book will serve as encouragement to the women she refers to as the “old birth mothers” who surrendered their children in the days before there was such a thing as an open adoption. Not knowing at the time of her daughter’s birth about a document called an affidavit of disclosure, Maher didn’t realize she could have provided more information about herself. “Everything was very different in those days,” she said.

Today, the two women are in frequent contact via e-mail and see each other often. DeCosse’s adoptive parents are accepting of the relationship she has with Maher.

“I think because we had our reunion later in life, we want to take advantage of the time we have to spend together,” said DeCosse, who refers to their relationship as a strong friendship.

“I see her as essentially the best friend you could possibly have,” she said, “and she is the woman who just happens to be my birth mother.”

Erin Merrigan, a parishioner at St. Joan of Arc in Minneapolis, surrendered her first-born son for adoption in 1981. She and husband, Mike, were unmarried at the time, just finishing college, and knew they were not prepared to raise a child.

The couple, now parents to four additional children, reunited with son Joe, 28, when he was 19 years old. They are in frequent contact, but only see their oldest once or twice a year since he moved to North Carolina, where he runs a business and is engaged to be married.

“Society doesn’t understand reunion in some ways. It’s hard to think of bringing everything back up,” Merrigan said. “But the truth of the matter is that birth mothers chose life. They cared enough to have that child, so of course, they have always loved and cared about them. They want to know how they are.”

Merrigan is a member of Concerned United Birthparents, a national support group for those involved in what is known as the adoption triad: Birth parents, adoptees and adoptive parents. The Twin Cities chapter meets monthly at the St. Louis Park Community Center.

“We’ve found the people who really aren’t being served are the adult adoptees. We want to see more birth mothers come out of the woodwork. Unfortunately, these are women who had no support when they gave birth to their child. Many have never talked about the experience to anyone,” Merrigan said.

She believes that when it comes to the subject of reunion, the best outcome will result if all members of the triad “accept everyone; be loving, honest, caring and collaborative.”

In her discussions with other birth mothers and adoptees, and as a result of her own journey, Maher said she understands the fear of risk and rejection that comes with the prospect of reunion. For that reason, she is especially grateful for the outcome of her own re-connection with DeCosse.

“It just felt like it was meant to be,” Maher said. “The time had come when there were things we had to do in this life together.”

For more about Concerned United Birth parents, contact Erin Merrigan at (612) 824-3470. To learn more about “Fifty Years in 13 Days” by Jackie Maher and Katie DeCosse, visit www.wowpublishinggroup.com.

Did you enjoy this article?

Click HERE to learn how you can help support the mission of The Catholic Spirit.

Comments (4)

...
Thank you for a very truthful telling of adoption reunions.
It so sad that so many mothers have been so conditionalized to feel that they have no right to search for their reliquished children. Meanwhile, the adopted adults have no way to access their true medical information which also affects thier OWN children.
If New York State would finially pass the NYS Adoptee Rights bill http://www.unsealedinitiative.org/, then Maher and DeCosse would not have had to pay for a PI, or have waited as long to have the realtionship they desired.

Even after 50 years, they are pretty lucky; most of the 6 million adoptees in the US still have no recourse to find their true idenites as the records are still sealed.

Claudia Corrigan D'Arcy
www.musingsofthelame.com
Claudia Corrigan D'Arcy , November 06, 2009
...
Thank you for sharing your story! I too gave up a child through Catholic Charities before there were open adoptions (1987). I have since been reunited with my daughter (reunited about 5 years ago thanks to the internet). I am so thankful as I had always held onto the hope of finding her. I think laws need to be changed to allow adoptees the right to know where they come from. If you talk to most birthparents they will tell you that their desire is to reconnect with their child. It is not right for lawmakers to ASSUME that we wish to be kept a secret from our children or that we wish to keep things a secret from our child. The system needs to be changed! My heart aches for those who have not reconnected. For those of us who know where we come from...... we are so blessed! For those of you who don't....... my heart aches for you. May God bless all of you who are still searching. May you find the truth and as a result be set free.
Becki , November 07, 2009
...
My son was given up for adoption in January 1977 (against my wishes). He was born on the 13th January 1977 and adopted by an Italian couple through the Catholic Womens' League in Pretoria, South Africa. For 32 years now I have tried unsuccesfully to find my son. He is a qualified and practising chartered accountant currently living in the U.S.A. I do not know his and his adoptive parents' names, and to be honest I am still feeling crushed by the whole experience, but I will not give up in my quest to find my son. Hopefully my plea for help and guidance will be read by a Good Samaritan.
Guy R Beckett
Tel : 011 672 5418
Fax : 011 672 4455
Cell : 083 271 0684
Email : This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Guy Randolph Beckett , December 13, 2009
Shane Desmond McCarthy
I was born Shane Desmond McCarthy in Germiston SA on 20 December 1969. I was adopted through a Catholic institution. I thought it was Nazareth House in Jhb but they claim not to have any records. I was adopted at 1½ years and my name was changed to Grant Scott Eddy
Shane Desmond McCarthy , February 06, 2010

Write comment

smaller | bigger
security image
Write the displayed characters

busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 19 November 2009 )
 
Next >